Whole Peanut Bird Feeder Homemade: Options Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Details
A whole peanut bird feeder offers peanuts in the shell to birds that take them. None of the six listings below is homemade. They are ready-made feeders, and the feeder’s form and how it hangs decide what birds can reach and how easily you can fill it.
All six list a hanging mount, so the deciding factors are size, material, capacity and what comes in the box. Check the space where you will hang the feeder first.
Quick answer
Four are wood or cedar feeders, one is a round metal feeder and one is the ROSSGO peanut wreath 2-pack. For the one listing with a stated hook and a two-pack, choose the ROSSGO. For a slim long feeder, the Backyard Birds Unlimited cedar feeder is 20.5 in long. The first listing shows a 1 in size that is unlikely to be the real feeder size, so confirm it before comparing.
Comparison table
| Product | Form | Size | Material | Capacity / weight | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round Metal Peanut Feeder | Round metal feeder | 1 x 1 x 1 in (confirm) | Metal | 2 pounds capacity, 4.8 oz | 1 |
| ROSSGO Peanut Wreath, 2 Pack | Wreath feeders | 11.7 L x 3 W x 15.7 H in | Not stated | Not stated | 2 |
| Crow Feeder for Outside | Solid wood feeder | 10 L x 6 W x 12 H in | Wood (per title) | 1.5 pounds capacity | 1 |
| Backyard Birds Unlimited Cedar | Cedar feeder | 20.5 L x 2.5 W x 2.5 H in | Cedar Wood, Wire | 8 oz | 1 |
| Crow Feeder, Wooden Peanut | Wood and acrylic feeder | 8.7 L x 6.7 W x 13 H in | Acrylic, Wood | Not stated | 1 |
| Square Crow Feeder | Solid wood feeder | 10.3 L x 10.3 W x 13.2 H in | Wood | 5 pounds | 1 |
Product reviews
Peanut Bird Feeder, Hanging Round Metal Whole Wild Bird Feeder
What it is: A round metal feeder with a hanging hook in the title, described as rust proof and for outdoor birds and squirrels. The listing gives Item Dimensions as 1 in L x 1 in W x 1 in H, Metal, Hanging Mount, 1 item, 4.8 ounces and Capacity 2 pounds.
Who it suits: Buyers who want a metal feeder with a stated capacity.
Pros
- Capacity is stated.
- Metal material is stated.
- Light, at 4.8 ounces.
Cons
- The 1 in dimensions are not credible for a feeder, so the real size is unconfirmed.
- The rust proof claim comes from the title only.
Skip if: you need a confirmed size before buying.
View the round metal peanut feeder on Amazon (affiliate link)
ROSSGO Pack of 2 Peanut Bird Feeder, Outdoor Peanut Wreath
What it is: A pack of 2 peanut wreath feeders in green. The listing gives 11.7 in L x 3 in W x 15.7 in H, Hanging Mount and Hook as an included component.
Who it suits: Buyers who want two feeders and a hook in one order.
Pros
- Two feeders in the pack.
- Hook is listed as included.
- Size is stated.
Cons
- No material or capacity is stated.
Skip if: you need the material confirmed.
View the ROSSGO peanut wreath 2-pack on Amazon (affiliate link)
Crow Feeder for Outside, Hanging Whole Peanut Feeder
What it is: A hanging solid wood feeder whose title says it attracts crows, large birds, woodpeckers and blue jays. The listing gives 10 in L x 6 in W x 12 in H, Hanging Mount, 1 item, Capacity 1.5 pounds and Color wood.
Who it suits: Buyers who want a mid-size wood feeder with a stated capacity.
Pros
- Capacity and size are stated.
- Title names the birds it targets.
Cons
- No Material field is listed, so wood rests on the title.
- No weight is stated.
Skip if: you need a hook included or the weight confirmed.
View the Crow Feeder for Outside on Amazon (affiliate link)
Backyard Birds Unlimited Cedar Whole In-Shell Peanut Feeder, 21 Inch
What it is: A slim cedar feeder made in the USA, according to the title, for whole in-shell peanuts. The listing gives 20.5 in L x 2.5 in W x 2.5 in H, Cedar Wood and Wire, Hanging Mount, 1 item and 8 ounces.
Who it suits: Buyers who want a long, slim feeder in cedar.
Pros
- Cedar material is stated.
- Title names whole in-shell peanuts directly.
- Light, at 8 ounces.
Cons
- No capacity is stated.
- At 20.5 in long, it needs a tall hanging spot.
Skip if: you want a feeder with a stated capacity.
View the Backyard Birds Unlimited cedar feeder on Amazon (affiliate link)
Crow Feeder, Wooden Peanut Bird Feeder for Blue Jays and Large Birds
What it is: A hanging feeder in acrylic and wood for blue jays and large birds, per the title. The listing gives 8.7 in L x 6.7 in W x 13 in H, Hanging Mount, 1 item and Color Walnut.
Who it suits: Buyers who want the smallest footprint among the wood crow-style feeders.
Pros
- Material and size are stated.
- Compact footprint compared with the other crow feeders.
Cons
- No capacity or weight is stated.
Skip if: you need capacity or weight confirmed.
View the Crow Feeder for blue jays on Amazon (affiliate link)
Square Crow Feeder, Hanging Whole Peanut Bird Feeder
What it is: A square solid wood hanging feeder whose title says it attracts crows, woodpeckers, large birds and blue jays. The listing gives 10.3 in L x 10.3 in W x 13.2 in H, Wood, Hanging Mount, 1 item and 5 pounds.
Who it suits: Buyers who want a larger wood feeder and have a strong hanging point.
Pros
- Material and size are stated.
- Solid wood, per the title.
Cons
- The heaviest feeder here, at 5 pounds.
- No capacity is stated.
Skip if: your hook or branch cannot take 5 pounds.
View the Square Crow Feeder on Amazon (affiliate link)
Buying checklist
- Measure the hanging space for both width and height.
- Check that your hook or branch can carry the weight. The Square Crow Feeder lists 5 pounds.
- Check capacity where stated: 2 pounds for the round metal feeder and 1.5 pounds for the Crow Feeder for Outside.
- Check whether a hook is included. Only the ROSSGO lists one.
- Confirm the material where it is missing, as for the ROSSGO.
FAQ
Are any of these homemade?
No. All six are bought peanut feeders with a hanging mount. They are offered as ready-made alternatives to a homemade feeder.
Which feeders list a capacity?
Two: the round metal feeder at 2 pounds and the Crow Feeder for Outside at 1.5 pounds. The other four list none.
Which feeder includes a hook?
The ROSSGO lists a Hook as an included component, and the round metal feeder title mentions a hanging hook. The other listings do not state one.
Which is the largest and which is the smallest?
The cedar feeder is the longest at 20.5 in L but only 2.5 in wide. The Square Crow Feeder is the widest at 10.3 in L x 10.3 in W. The round metal feeder shows 1 in dimensions, which look wrong.
Which birds are these for?
The crow feeder titles name crows, woodpeckers, blue jays and large birds. The cedar feeder title names whole in-shell peanuts. The listings do not say more than that.
What if a detail is missing?
Treat it as unknown and confirm it on the current page. The ROSSGO lists no material and four listings list no capacity.
Closing note
For most buyers the choice is size and weight against hanging space. If you would like to make your own food, see Best Diy Bird Feeder Peanut Butter or Best Homemade Bird Food with Peanut Butter. If squirrels are a worry, see Best Brome Squirrel Buster Plus Squirrel Proof Bird Feeder or Best Brome Squirrel Solution 200 Bird Feeder.
