Wood Tabletop and Propane Table Fire Pits: 2 Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Details
A propane fire table and a small wood fire pit do different jobs, so the first question is whether you want a fire at table height or a pit you can move. The Shintenchi 43-inch unit is a rectangular propane table, 22 inches deep and 24.5 inches high, with a 60,000 BTU figure in its title and the tank sold separately. The HGD tabletop pit is a 5.5-inch wood-or-pellet pit that weighs 1.7 pounds. This page compares the two listings and uses a wood fire safety guide from Albany, New York, for the wood side only.
Quick answer
- Choose the HGD for a small wood or pellet pit you can carry, with a 1.7-pound weight and a carry bag named in the title.
- Choose the Shintenchi if you want a propane fire surface at table height, which the listing says can also work as a dining, coffee or bar table. The listing gives 24.5 inches as the height.
- The Shintenchi listing does not say whether a propane tank is included, and its bullet says the tank is not included, so plan for a tank separately.
- The two are not alternatives for the same spot. One is a portable pit and the other is a table-height unit, so choose by how the fire will be used.
Side-by-side listing data
The table gives only what each listing states. Where a field is missing, the cell says so.
| Field | HGD Tabletop (ASIN B0D8VP3YNX) | Shintenchi 43-inch table (ASIN B0D7ZVDYHX) |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel | Wood (specification); wood or pellets (bullet) | Liquefied petroleum gas (specification) |
| Size | 5.5 by 5.5 by 8 inches | 22 deep by 43 wide by 24.5 high inches |
| Item weight | 1.7 pounds | 50 pounds |
| Material | Stainless steel, silver | Alloy steel and stone, black; powder coated |
| Heat output | Not stated | 60,000 BTU (title and bullet) |
| Certification | Not stated | CSA certification (title); the bullets do not state its scope |
| Included | Carry bag (title); removable ash grate (bullet) | Lid and waterproof cover (bullet) |
| Propane tank | Not applicable | Not included (bullet); tank size not stated |
| Intended use | Camping and backyard use (title); s’mores (bullet) | Outdoor dining, coffee or bar table (bullet) |
| Warranty | Not stated | Not stated |
| Clearance from walls | Not stated | Not stated |
A pit or a table?
The Shintenchi is a table first and a fire second. Its bullet describes it as usable as an outdoor dining, coffee or bar table, and the listing gives a 24.5-inch height. That height is a fixed figure in the listing, and the listing does not say whether it suits a particular chair or bench. The HGD is a pit: it sits low, holds a small wood or pellet fire, and is designed to be carried from one place to another.
That difference changes the question you should ask. If the fire will sit in the middle of a dining space with people eating around it, a table at 24.5 inches is the relevant figure. If the fire will move between a patio, a yard and a camping trip, the HGD’s size and weight are the relevant figures. Neither listing gives a seating height or a seat-to-table distance, so check those before you decide.
Footprint and weight, worked out
The base area is length times width. The HGD base is 5.5 x 5.5 = 30.25 square inches. The Shintenchi is 22 x 43 = 946 square inches. Dividing gives 946 divided by 30.25, which is about 31.3, so the table covers about 31 times the floor of the HGD on the listed sizes.
Weight is the other large difference. The Shintenchi’s 50 pounds divided by the HGD’s 1.7 pounds is about 29.4, so the table weighs about 29 times as much as the pit on the listed figures. Those ratios make the two units different in how they are moved and placed, which is why they are not interchangeable.
| Measure | HGD | Shintenchi | Shintenchi divided by HGD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base area (length x width) | 30.25 sq in | 946 sq in | 31.3 |
| Item weight | 1.7 lb | 50 lb | 29.4 |
| Height | 8 in | 24.5 in | 3.1 |
Heat: the one figure both sides differ on
The Shintenchi gives 60,000 BTU in its title and repeats the figure in a bullet, so that is the only heat figure in either listing. The HGD gives no heat output or fuel-burn figure, so the two cannot be compared on heat. Neither gives a surface temperature, a clearance from walls, or a spark or ember measurement.
A table-height propane fire is a heat source close to people, so the missing clearance figures matter more here than on a small pit. Check the manual and the local fire authority for the distance from the table to walls, overhangs and furniture, because neither listing gives it.
Propane: the tank, the cover and the certification
The Shintenchi bullet says the tank is not included, and the listing does not state the tank size. Because the tank is a separate purchase and the listing does not name a size, the setup cost and the connection cannot be fully planned from this listing alone. Confirm the tank size and the regulator with the product page or the manual before you buy.
The title says CSA certification, and the bullets describe a lid and a waterproof cover for storage. The bullets do not give the scope of the certification, so read the title as a claim and check the certification details on the product page. The lid and cover are listed as included, which helps for storage when the table is not in use.
Keep the table outdoors, follow the manual for connection and use, and do not treat the title’s heat figure as a measured output. The manual is the reference for installation and storage, and this guide does not describe installation steps beyond what the listing says.
Wood fire safety for the HGD
The Albany, New York Department of Fire and Emergency Services guide on outdoor fire pits sets the practical limits for a wood fire. It advises building the pit at least 10 feet from homes, fences and trees. It advises keeping children and pets at least 3 feet from the fire, and warns against soft woods such as pine and cedar because they can pop and throw sparks. It says not to start a fire with gasoline or lighter fluid, to keep a fire extinguisher, garden hose or bucket of sand close by, and to avoid lighting a fire on windy days.
The HGD listing describes a double-wall design with vent holes that reduces smoke. That is the listing’s design claim. No wood fire is smoke-free, so treat the low-smoke wording as a claim to confirm, not a result. The Albany guide does not cover propane, so its wood rules apply to the HGD and not to the Shintenchi.
Product
1. HGD Tabletop Fire Pit, Silver (ASIN B0D8VP3YNX)
Why it is in the set: it is the portable wood option in the research set. A 1.7-pound weight, a 5.5-inch square base and a carry bag named in the title make it the easier unit to move between a patio, a yard and a camping spot.
Skip if: you want a propane fire, a surface at table height, or a unit that a group can sit around for a meal. The listing gives an 8-inch height and no heat output.
One limit: the fuel field says wood and a bullet adds pellets, so confirm the fuel on the product page before you buy.
2. Shintenchi 43-Inch Propane Fire Pit Table, Black (ASIN B0D7ZVDYHX)
Why it is in the set: it is the table-height propane option in the research set, with a 43-inch width, a stated 60,000 BTU and a lid and waterproof cover listed as included. The bullet describes it as usable for dining, coffee or bar service.
Skip if: the fire will move around, you cannot place a 22 by 43 inch footprint, or you cannot buy and store a propane tank. At 50 pounds, it is not a portable pit.
One limit: the tank is not included and its size is not stated, and the CSA certification scope is not explained in the bullets.
Buying checklist
- Decide whether the fire needs to move. If it does, the HGD’s weight and size fit that need, and the Shintenchi’s 50 pounds does not.
- Measure the space for the Shintenchi’s 22 by 43 inch footprint, with room for chairs and walking around it.
- Check whether the table’s 24.5-inch height suits the seating you plan to use. The listing does not give a seating height.
- For the Shintenchi, confirm the tank size and regulator fit, since the listing does not state the tank size.
- For the HGD, confirm the fuel is wood or pellets as you intend, and keep it outdoors.
- For either unit, get the clearance from walls and overhangs from the manual or the local fire authority.
Mistakes to avoid
- Treating the two as alternatives for the same spot. A 1.7-pound pit and a 50-pound table serve different uses.
- Assuming the Shintenchi includes a tank. The bullet says it is not included.
- Comparing heat output. Only the Shintenchi gives a heat figure, and it is in the title and a bullet, not a specification field.
- Placing the table close to walls or furniture. The listing gives no clearance, so the distance has to come from the manual or the local authority.
- Treating the low-smoke wording on the HGD as a promise. No wood fire is smoke-free.
How we chose
The research for this keyword held two listings, and both are reviewed here. The criteria were the figures each listing states: fuel, size, weight, heat output where given, included parts, intended use, and safety wording. Both listings were opened on 2026-10-21, and their titles and key figures were read. The detail fields come from the listing record dated 2026-10-12. For the wood side this page draws on the Albany guide, a city fire department document. No propane-specific guide was opened for this comparison.
What we could not verify
- The Shintenchi’s tank size, and whether a tank is sold with it.
- The scope of the CSA certification named in the title.
- The table’s suitability for dining. The bullet describes it as usable for dining, but the listing gives no seating height.
- Clearance from walls and overhangs for either unit.
- Whether the HGD takes pellets, since the fuel field and the bullet differ.
- Any warranty for either unit. The Shintenchi listing gives none in the fields read.
- The live listing text. When the product pages were opened on 2026-10-21, the titles and key figures were read, and the other detail fields come from the listing record dated 2026-10-12.
FAQ
Which of these pits burns wood?
The HGD does. Its fuel field says wood, and a bullet adds pellets. The Shintenchi is listed as propane.
Is the Shintenchi a table?
The bullet describes it as an outdoor fire pit table that can be used as a dining, coffee or bar table. Its listed height is 24.5 inches.
Does the Shintenchi include a propane tank?
No. The bullet says the tank is not included, and the listing does not state the tank size. Confirm the tank size and regulator before you buy.
What BTU rating does the Shintenchi list?
The title gives 60,000 BTU, and a bullet repeats the figure. The listing does not give it in a specification field.
Can the HGD be used near a wall or fence?
Neither listing gives a clearance. The Albany fire department guide advises at least 10 feet from homes, fences and trees for a wood fire, and the local fire authority should confirm the distance where you live.
Related guides
For another propane tabletop option, read Flame King 24-Inch Propane Fire Pit Review. For the tank side of a propane setup, read Best 20 Lb Propane Tank for Patio Heater Setup. For tabletop gas heating options, read Best Tabletop Gas Patio Heater: 4 Picks Compared.
Bottom line
Choose by use. If you want a fire you can carry and a small wood or pellet pit, the HGD fits. If you want a propane fire surface at table height that can serve as a dining or bar table, the Shintenchi fits, provided you buy the tank separately and confirm its size and clearance before you place it.
Sources
- Amazon product listing for ASIN B0D8VP3YNX (HGD Tabletop Fire Pit), https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0D8VP3YNX (page opened 2026-10-21, title read; specification fields as recorded in the listing record dated 2026-10-12)
- Amazon product listing for ASIN B0D7ZVDYHX (Shintenchi 43-inch propane fire pit table), https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0D7ZVDYHX (page opened 2026-10-21, title, size and BTU read; other fields as recorded in the listing record dated 2026-10-12)
- Albany, New York Department of Fire and Emergency Services, “Outdoor Fire Pits” guide (PDF; undated), https://albanyny.gov/DocumentCenter/View/888/Outdoor-Fire-Pits-PDF (opened 2026-10-21)
Disclosure: links to Amazon on this site are affiliate links, and a qualifying purchase can earn this site a commission. The full policy is on the disclosure page.
