Tabletop Fire Pits, Wood and Propane: 2 Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Details
A tabletop fire pit and a propane fire bowl are different tools, and the choice starts with fuel. The HGD tabletop pit is a small stainless steel unit that the listing says burns wood and can also take pellets. The Outland Living 19-inch pit runs on propane from a tank the listing says is sold separately. This comparison uses the two listings and a wood fire safety guide from Albany, New York. It does not rank the two on heat output, because the HGD listing states none.
Quick answer
- Choose the HGD if you want a wood fire in a small footprint: 5.5 inches square, 8 inches tall and 1.7 pounds, with a carry bag named in the title.
- Choose the Outland if you want propane in a 19-inch bowl. Plan for a 20-pound propane tank, because the listing says it is not included.
- The HGD listing gives no heat output or clearance. The Outland title gives 58,000 BTU, and neither listing gives a clearance from walls.
- Settle the HGD fuel question first: the specification field says wood, and a bullet adds pellets.
Side-by-side listing data
The table gives only what each listing states. Where a field is missing, the cell says so.
| Field | HGD Tabletop (ASIN B0D8VP3YNX) | Outland Living 893 (ASIN B00KY4S388) |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel | Wood (specification); wood or pellets (bullet) | Liquefied petroleum gas (specification) |
| Size | 5.5 by 5.5 by 8 inches | 19 by 19 by 11 inches |
| Item weight | 1.7 pounds | 23 pounds |
| Material | Stainless steel, silver | Alloy steel and stainless steel, black |
| Heat output | Not stated | 58,000 BTU (title) |
| Included | Carry bag (title); removable ash grate (bullet) | Cover and carry kit; pre-attached 10-foot hose and regulator; lava rock set; tank stabilizer ring |
| Propane tank | Not applicable | Not included (bullet) |
| Safety wording | Not stated | CSA approved, and described as safe during most campfire bans; the bullet tells buyers to check local restrictions |
| Warranty | Not stated | One-year limited warranty (specification) |
| Clearance from walls | Not stated | Not stated beyond the campfire-ban wording |
Fuel comes first
The HGD is a wood pit on the listing’s own specification field, which reads wood. One bullet adds that it takes pellets as well, and the title names a carry bag but not a fuel. Because the two statements differ, the pellet use should be confirmed on the product page before you buy pellets or plan around them.
The Outland is a propane pit, and the specification field reads liquefied petroleum gas. The listing says the 20-pound propane tank is not included, so the true cost of the setup is the pit plus a tank, and the tank has to be bought separately. The listing also includes a pre-attached 10-foot hose with a regulator, which connects the tank to the burner. A propane unit is a gas appliance, so the manual that comes with it is the reference for connection, storage and use.
Footprint and weight, worked out
Two numbers tell most of the story: the base area and the weight. The base area is length times width, so the HGD is 5.5 x 5.5 = 30.25 square inches, and the Outland is 19 x 19 = 361 square inches. The Outland covers 361 divided by 30.25, which is about 11.9 times the floor of the HGD on the listed sizes.
Weight runs the other way in proportion. The Outland weighs 23 pounds and the HGD 1.7 pounds, so the propane bowl is about 13.5 times heavier on the listed weights. Those two ratios explain most of the difference in how each unit is moved and where it can sit.
| Measure | HGD | Outland | Outland divided by HGD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base area (length x width) | 30.25 sq in | 361 sq in | 11.9 |
| Item weight | 1.7 lb | 23 lb | 13.5 |
| Height | 8 in | 11 in | 1.4 |
The height ratio is smaller than the others, so the Outland sits only moderately taller. For a seat-height question, neither listing gives a seat height, so the table cannot answer it.
Heat and clearance: what is and is not stated
The Outland title gives 58,000 BTU. The HGD listing gives no heat figure, so the two cannot be compared on output. Neither listing gives a clearance from walls, fences or overhead structures, and neither gives a surface temperature or an ember-throw measurement. Those are the figures a buyer most needs before placing a fire, so check the product pages and the manuals for them.
The Outland bullet describes the unit as safe during most campfire bans and tells buyers to check current fire restrictions. Read that as the manufacturer’s claim. Fire restrictions are set locally and change, so the bullet does not replace a check with your local fire authority.
Wood fire safety for the HGD
The Albany, New York Department of Fire and Emergency Services guide on outdoor fire pits sets practical limits for wood fires. It advises building the pit at least 10 feet from homes, fences and trees. It advises keeping children and pets at least 3 feet from the fire, and warns against soft woods such as pine and cedar because they can pop and throw sparks. It says not to start a fire with gasoline or lighter fluid, to keep a fire extinguisher, garden hose or bucket of sand nearby, and to avoid lighting a fire on windy days.
The HGD listing describes a double-wall design with vent holes that reduces smoke, and it includes a removable ash grate. The low-smoke wording is the listing’s design claim. No wood fire is smoke-free, so do not treat that wording as a promise of a smoke-free fire. The Albany guide does not cover propane, so the wood rules above apply to the HGD and not to the Outland.
Propane: what the listing says and what it leaves out
The Outland listing says the pit is CSA approved and safe during most campfire bans, and it includes a cover, a carry kit and a pre-attached 10-foot hose with a regulator. The listing names a 20-pound propane tank as the standard tank and says that tank is not included. Keep the unit outdoors and follow the manual for connection and storage. The Albany guide was not written for propane units, and the Outland manual was not among the sources opened for this guide, so the propane rules here come from the listing and the manual that ships with the unit.
A propane bowl also needs a tank that fits the regulator. The listing gives the tank size as 20 pounds and includes a stabilizer ring, so confirm the tank and the ring fit before you buy. Keep the tank outdoors, and check the connection before use as the manual describes.
Product
1. HGD Tabletop Fire Pit, Silver (ASIN B0D8VP3YNX)
Why it is in the set: it is the smallest and lightest unit in the research set, with a 1.7-pound weight, a 5.5-inch square base and a carry bag named in the title. It suits a wood fire on a small patio, balcony or camping trip, where the listing’s own use list points.
Skip if: you need propane, a larger fire, or a unit that sits at table height. The listing gives no heat output, so do not buy it for a specific heat need.
One limit: the fuel field says wood and a bullet adds pellets, so confirm the fuel before you buy.
2. Outland Living 19-Inch Propane Fire Pit, Black (ASIN B00KY4S388)
Why it is in the set: it is the propane option in the research set, with a 19-inch base, a stated 58,000 BTU in its title, and a cover, carry kit and pre-attached hose listed as included.
Skip if: you cannot buy or store a 20-pound propane tank, you want a wood fire, or you need a low seat-height table. The listing gives an 11-inch height.
One limit: the tank is not included, and the campfire-ban wording is the manufacturer’s claim, not a ruling on your area.
Buying checklist
- Confirm the HGD fuel on the product page, and whether pellets are supported.
- For the Outland, include the cost of a separate 20-pound propane tank in the total setup, and check that the regulator and stabilizer ring fit it.
- Measure the space: 5.5 inches square for the HGD and 19 inches square for the Outland, plus room around each unit.
- Check clearance from walls, fences and overhead structures in the manual or with the local fire authority, since neither listing gives it.
- Check local fire restrictions before lighting either unit.
- Keep both units outdoors, and follow the manual that ships with the unit.
Mistakes to avoid
- Assuming the HGD burns gas because it is a fire pit. The specification field says wood, and the title names no fuel.
- Assuming the Outland includes a tank. The listing says the 20-pound tank is not included.
- Comparing heat output using the title alone. The Outland has a 58,000 BTU title figure, and the HGD listing has none.
- Placing a wood pit too close to a fence or home. The Albany guide sets 10 feet from homes, fences and trees.
- Treating low-smoke wording as a promise. The listing describes the design that way, and no wood fire is smoke-free.
How we chose
The research for this keyword held two listings, and both are reviewed here. The criteria were the figures each listing states: fuel, size, weight, heat output where given, included parts, and safety wording. Each listing was opened on 2026-10-21 and its title was read; the detail fields come from the listing record dated 2026-10-12. For wood-fire rules this page draws on the Albany guide, which is a city fire department document. No propane-specific guide was opened, so propane rules come from the listing and the manual that ships with the unit.
What we could not verify
- Heat output for the HGD. The listing gives none.
- Clearance from walls, fences and overhead structures for either unit. Neither listing gives it.
- The scope of the Outland’s CSA approval, which the bullet describes without a standard number.
- Whether the HGD takes pellets, since the fuel field and the bullet differ.
- Whether the Albany guide’s distances apply where you live. The guide is from one city, and fire rules are local.
- The Outland’s warranty beyond the one-year figure in the specification field.
- The live listing text. When the product pages were opened on 2026-10-21, only the titles were read, so the detail fields come from the listing record dated 2026-10-12.
FAQ
Can the HGD pit burn propane?
The listing does not say it can. The specification field reads wood, and a bullet adds pellets. Do not assume gas use from the title.
Does the Outland include a propane tank?
No. The bullet says the 20-pound propane tank is not included, so buy one separately and confirm it fits the regulator.
Is the Outland safe during campfire bans?
The listing says it is safe to use during most campfire bans, and it tells buyers to check current restrictions. Treat that as the manufacturer’s claim, and check your local fire rules before you light it.
How far should a wood pit sit from a house or fence?
The Albany fire department guide advises at least 10 feet from homes, fences and trees. Neither listing gives its own clearance, so use the guide’s distance as a starting point and confirm it with your local fire authority.
Which unit is easier to carry?
The HGD, at 1.7 pounds, with a carry bag named in the title. The Outland is listed at 23 pounds with a carry kit, and it is a larger unit to move with the tank as well.
Related guides
For a propane tabletop pit with a different footprint, read Allen and Roth Gas Tabletop Fire Pit: Key Checks. For the tank that feeds a propane pit, read Best Propane Tank for Gas Fire Pit: Setup Guide. For the regulator and burner side, read Best Air Mixer for Propane Fire Pit: 6 Picks That Fit.
Bottom line
Choose by fuel first. The HGD is the light wood-or-pellet pit for a small space, and the Outland is the heavier propane bowl with a cover and hose, which needs a separately bought tank. Confirm the HGD fuel, the Outland tank and the clearance for either unit before you buy.
Sources
- Amazon product listing for ASIN B0D8VP3YNX (HGD Tabletop Fire Pit), https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0D8VP3YNX (page opened 2026-10-21, title read; specification fields as recorded in the listing record dated 2026-10-12)
- Amazon product listing for ASIN B00KY4S388 (Outland Living Portable Propane Fire Pit, 19-inch), https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00KY4S388 (page opened 2026-10-21, title read; specification fields as recorded in the listing record dated 2026-10-12)
- Albany, New York Department of Fire and Emergency Services, “Outdoor Fire Pits” guide (PDF; undated), https://albanyny.gov/DocumentCenter/View/888/Outdoor-Fire-Pits-PDF (opened 2026-10-21)
Disclosure: links to Amazon on this site are affiliate links, and a qualifying purchase can earn this site a commission. The full policy is on the disclosure page.
