As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

A layer of material spread over the soil surface sits between the soil and the air, so less water leaves the soil directly. University of California researchers and Oregon State University Extension both describe this role, but they also show that it is not automatic. The mulch itself can hold and lose water, and the amount saved depends on the material, its depth and how often the bed is watered. The sections below cover what the sources measured and where they stop.

At a glance

  • Mulch sits over the soil surface and works as an insulating layer. Oregon State says that in summer, pushing mulch back over the root zone “will minimize evaporation and moderate changes in soil temperature.”
  • The mulch itself holds water. In a California field study, water losses from the mulch treatments ranged from 0.0 to 0.18 inches per day, and mulches that held the most water lost the most.
  • In one California test at Quail Gardens, a 3-inch Gro-Mulch layer did not differ from bare soil or fabric-covered soil in water lost to the air over five days after irrigation.
  • Drip irrigation was expected to minimize evaporative loss, while overhead watering needed longer gaps between irrigations to limit loss from the mulch.

What mulch is supposed to do

Oregon State University Extension lists several jobs for mulch, including reducing soil compaction from rain, minimizing erosion, suppressing weeds, warming the soil, insulating it from extreme temperatures, and keeping the soil moist. Its list places “reduce evaporation” alongside those other goals. Its guide describes organic mulch as a layer that “will decompose over time,” and recommends spreading a layer of 2 to 4 inches on the soil surface around plants.

The University of California study starts from the same claim. Its authors write that “mulches can benefit landscapes by reducing soil evaporation, cooling the soil, suppressing weed growth, and possibly providing nutrients for plant growth.” They add that many programs promote mulch “primarily to reduce evaporation from soil.” The study then points out a gap: “little information or standards have been developed on the water holding capacity or evaporation rate of mulch materials themselves.”

That gap is the reason the field work matters. A mulch can reduce evaporation from the soil below it and still lose a meaningful amount of water from its own layer. Both effects need to be counted when judging how much water a bed actually keeps. For the way water leaves bare soil over time, see how soil surface evaporation shifts between two stages, and for how water enters the ground, see what controls soil infiltration rate.

How the California study was run

David Shaw, Dennis Pittenger and Mark McMaster, writing for the University of California Cooperative Extension and partners, measured mulches in full sun at two sites in San Diego County. One was Cuyamaca College in El Cajon, an inland valley site. The other was Quail Botanical Gardens in Encinitas, a coastal site. The authors describe the sites as representing “inland valley (El Cajon) and coastal (Encinitas) climatic conditions.”

The team tested twelve treatments. These covered a range of materials and depths, with a common landscape suggestion of “2-4 inches of mulch” used as a reference point. The study was run on the mulch alone, “independent of plant materials,” so it measured the mulch and soil rather than the growth of any plant. Results are reported as inches of water held and inches lost over time.

The authors also explain why the work was needed. In one failing landscape they examined, sprinkler water was “not penetrating through the mulch layer,” and frequent applications “appeared to be absorbed and evaporated from the mulch, resulting in under-irrigation and plant death.” Water that never reached the soil was lost from the mulch surface, which is a different problem from the one mulch is usually credited with solving.

How much water the mulches held and lost

The water-holding results varied widely. The authors report that “the water holding capacities of the mulch treatments ranged from 0.0 in. for the control and fabric treatments to 1.1 in. for the 5-in. depth yardwaste treatment.” Expressed per foot of depth, values ran from 0.0 inches for the control and fabric treatments to 0.09 inches for 1-inch rock and 3.64 inches for the Gro-Mulch treatment. Deeper layers of organic material held more water in total.

Losses followed the same pattern. The paper says that “water losses from mulch treatments ranged from 0.0 to 0.18 inches per day,” and that “mulches with the highest water holding capacity lost the most water.” The Gro-Mulch treatment at 3 inches and the yardwaste treatments at 3 and 5 inches had the highest amounts held and the highest rates of loss. Rock held the least water and lost the least in each experiment.

The timing also matters. The authors note that “all mulch treatments lost the most amount of water on the first day after irrigation.” Losses slowed after that. For bark, Organic Ground Cover and a 1-inch yardwaste layer, the authors state that evaporation “during the first two days after irrigation exceeded 40 percent of ETo.” ETo is a standard measure of reference evapotranspiration, so this figure compares the mulch’s loss with the water a reference crop would use in the same period.

Where mulch did and did not cut loss from the soil

The most direct test of the soil-saving claim came at Quail Gardens. There, the authors found that “water loss was not significantly different between soil, soil covered with fabric, and soil covered with Gro-Mulch for five days following irrigation.” In their words, “although the Gro-Mulch may be insulating soil from moisture loss, the water lost to the atmosphere is not different from bare soil or fabric covered soil.”

This does not mean mulch never reduces evaporation. It means that, in this experiment, a particular mulch did not lower the total water leaving the bed over that five-day window compared with bare soil. The authors found that rock and the Xerimulch product had the least evaporative loss of all treatments, and that bark, Organic Ground Cover and yardwaste lost more over the first two days. The result depends on the material chosen, and not every mulch behaves like the one tested at Quail Gardens.

The authors also state that “the water holding capacity and evaporation data from the bark, OGC, Xerimulch, and rock show that these materials had minimal water loss after two days.” So some materials looked much better than others by the second day. The study did not test all mulches or all climates, and it was not designed to test the effect on plant growth.

How irrigation method changes the picture

The California authors linked their findings to irrigation practice. They wrote that under drip irrigation, “evaporative loss would be minimized and any mulch material could be selected.” With overhead sprinklers, they suggested “coarser mulches with lower water holding capacity or a thinner layer of mulch” could be used.

For overhead systems, the authors gave a timing rule for the conditions they tested. They concluded that “overhead irrigation should not be applied more frequently than every six or seven days in similar environmental conditions.” At that interval, they wrote, “the irrigation manager is taking advantage of the insulative properties of mulches while minimizing the evaporative loss from the mulch itself.” Frequent light watering wastes more water, because the mulch surface is wetted and evaporates the water before it reaches the root zone.

Irrigation managers would need to allow for the water the mulch holds. The paper advises that the manager “should know the amount of water held by the mulch and apply additional water to compensate for this amount.” This is a practical point for a garden bed as well: a thick mulch layer can absorb a light sprinkle before any water reaches the soil.

What the extension guide adds

The Oregon State guide focuses on how to apply mulch and when to adjust it, rather than measuring loss. It says to spread a layer of organic mulch “2 to 4 inches” deep on the soil surface, without covering the plants or the crown. It also advises that in summer, “before temperatures climb, push the mulch back to cover the root zone. This will minimize evaporation and moderate changes in soil temperature.” In spring, the same guide says to pull mulch back so the root zone warms faster.

The guide also warns about depth. It says that “a layer that is too deep could turn slimy or form a dry crust which prevents water from penetrating.” That warning matches the California finding that a thick layer can hold a large amount of water while blocking water from reaching the soil. On plastic, the guide says that “plastic mulch reduces evaporation as well,” but it also notes that ultraviolet light breaks the plastic down, so it must be replaced as needed.

How to read the evidence

Taken together, the sources support a few points. Mulch can cover the soil and reduce direct evaporation from it. Mulch can also store and release water on its own surface. A thicker or more absorbent mulch holds more water and can lose more of it. Watering that wets the mulch but not the soil can end up feeding evaporation. Gardeners should not expect every mulch to save water in the same way.

The sources do not give a single number for how much water any mulch saves in a home garden. They also do not give a watering schedule for vegetables, shrubs or lawns. The California tests were run on a specific set of materials at two coastal and inland sites in full sun. The Oregon guide is advice rather than measurement.

What remains unclear

The California data come from two San Diego County sites and a fixed set of mulch treatments. The Oregon guide does not report measurements of evaporation. The sources do not check whether the findings hold for heavy clay, for sandy soil, or for hot inland summers beyond the sites tested. The study also did not test planted beds, so its results do not show how mulch changes plant growth or total water use over a full season.

What the sources do not say

The sources do not give a percentage of evaporation saved by any mulch in a typical home garden. They do not compare organic mulches with plastic in measured evaporation, and they do not say how much mulch loss changes with rainfall rather than irrigation. They also do not say how long a mulch layer keeps its water-holding capacity as it breaks down.

Frequently asked questions

Does mulch always stop water from evaporating out of soil?

No. The California study found that one mulch did not differ from bare soil in water loss over five days after irrigation. Other materials had lower losses by the second day. The effect depends on the material and the conditions, and the study does not promise a fixed saving.

Why does mulch sometimes make watering less effective?

The California authors describe a landscape where sprinkler water did not penetrate the mulch, and frequent applications were absorbed and evaporated from it. The mulch layer held water that never reached the roots, which led to under-irrigation.

How deep should mulch be to reduce evaporation?

Oregon State recommends a layer of 2 to 4 inches of organic mulch on the soil surface. The California study used a 2-4 inch range as a common reference, and it found deeper organic layers held more water. The sources do not give a single depth that is best for evaporation alone.

Is plastic mulch better than organic mulch for saving water?

The Oregon guide says plastic mulch reduces evaporation, but the sources do not compare plastic and organic mulches side by side for water loss. They also do not measure the water-holding behaviour of plastic in the California tests.

How often should I water a bed that has mulch?

The California authors gave a timing rule for overhead systems under their test conditions: not more often than every six or seven days. They tied that rule to their site and climate, so it is not a general schedule. Drip systems were expected to lose less water to evaporation.

Sources

  • https://ucanr.edu/sites/default/files/2011-03/80238.pdf – Shaw D.A., Pittenger D.R., McMaster M. Water Retention and Evaporative Properties of Landscape Mulches. Proceedings of the 26th Annual Irrigation Show, Phoenix, AZ, 2005, Irrigation Association. University of California Cooperative Extension.
  • https://extension.oregonstate.edu/sites/extd8/files/documents/12281/gardeningwithmulch.pdf – Gardening with Mulches, 10-Minute University. Oregon Master Gardener Association, Clackamas County Chapter, in cooperation with Oregon State University Extension Service.