How Does Light Pollution Affect Night-Blooming Flowers?
Light pollution can reduce the number of nocturnal insects that visit night-blooming flowers, and fewer visits can mean less seed and fruit. A French study of flowers in artificially lit meadows recorded a 62 percent drop in visits by nocturnal pollinators such as moths, and a 13 percent drop in fruit production for one local plant. Night-blooming plants rely on dim light and scent to attract pollinators, and artificial light at night can interfere with both signals.
The short answer to how does light pollution affect night-blooming flowers is that it can reduce the number of nocturnal insects that visit night-blooming flowers, and fewer visits can mean less seed and fruit. A French study of flowers in artificially lit meadows recorded a 62 percent drop in visits by nocturnal pollinators such as moths, and a 13 percent drop in fruit production for one local plant. Night-blooming plants rely on dim light and scent to attract pollinators, and artificial light at night can interfere with both signals.
At a glance
- In the French meadow study, nocturnal pollinators visited flowers in lit areas far less often than flowers in unlit meadows.
- The researchers reported a 62 percent decrease in visits by nocturnal pollinators such as moths and certain beetles.
- A 13 percent decrease in fruit production was recorded for one local plant species, Cirsium oleraceum.
- The review of nocturnal pollination says artificial light at night threatens the dim-light processes that night-blooming plants and their pollinators depend on.
Someone searching for “how does light pollution affect night-blooming flowers” wants
A clear answer about whether a lit yard, porch or garden will reduce the pollinators that visit night-blooming plants, and whether it matters for fruit or seed. The sources below answer the question for the species and settings they describe. They do not give a lighting level for a home garden, and this post does not invent one.
What the meadow study measured
The clearest evidence comes from a press release by the French National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS), which describes a study by a European team that included a researcher from the Centre d’Écologie et des Sciences de la Conservation. The team studied flowers in meadows that were artificially lit and compared them with meadows that had no light pollution. The release says the researchers worked “by studying 24 hours per day flowers in artificially lit meadows.”
The main result is stated directly: the team “observed a 62% decrease in visits by nocturnal pollinators such as moths and certain Coleoptera, as compared with meadows with no light pollution.” Coleoptera are beetles.
The effect did not stop at visits. The release reports that the change “led to a 13% decrease in production of fruits of a local plant species, Cirsium oleraceum, despite numerous visits by diurnal pollinators such as bumblebees, bees and flies.” In other words, daytime insects kept visiting the plant, but the nocturnal visitors that the plant depends on for part of its pollination were fewer, and fruit production fell.
How night-blooming flowers attract pollinators
A review of nocturnal pollination describes the problem in detail. Its authors write that “Several plant species have opted to bloom at night, possibly as a response to aridity to prevent excessive water loss through evapotranspiration since flowering is often a water-demanding process, or to protect pollen from heat stress.” Night blooming is therefore a strategy with a purpose, not an accident.
Pollinators that work in the dark have to use other cues. The review notes that “Nocturnal pollinators have visual adaptations to function under dim light conditions but may also trade off vision against olfaction when they are dependent on nectar-rewarding and scented flowers.” Scent is therefore central for many night-blooming plants. The review also says that nocturnal pollinators “may use CO 2 and humidity cues emanating from freshly-opened flowers as indicators of nectar-rich resources.”
Artificial light can interfere with these cues. The review states that “Excessive and inappropriate illumination associated with anthropogenic activities has resulted in significant light pollution which serves to undermine life processes governed by dim light.” A moth that relies on faint light to navigate, or on scent to find a flower, may be drawn to a bright lamp instead. The review does not measure the pollinator’s path around a porch light, but it explains why a bright lamp can disrupt the system.
What this means for a garden
A night-blooming plant in a lit yard may get fewer nocturnal visits than the same plant in a darker spot. The sources do not measure a home garden, but the mechanism they describe is general: bright light affects the insects that pollinate at night.
- Use less light near night-blooming plants. The meadow study compared lit and unlit flowers, and the drop in visits was large. Dimmer light or less time lit is the simplest control.
- Shield fixtures. A fixture that points light down keeps light off the flowers and away from the air above them. This follows from the review’s point about illumination.
- Use motion sensors. A light that turns on only when someone walks by avoids constant light in the garden. Our guide to solar security lights with motion sensors covers the sensor settings the listings describe, though the listings do not mention pollinators. Our guide to solar motion-activated flood lights covers the same kind of settings for wider lighting.
- Leave dark corridors. Keep some beds and paths unlit, especially near the plants you want nocturnal insects to visit.
What remains unclear
- The sources do not confirm a safe lighting level for a home garden. The sources do not give one.
- The sources do not confirm how many night-blooming plants in North America are affected. The meadow study names one local plant, Cirsium oleraceum, for the fruit result.
- The sources do not confirm whether the reduction in visits leads to lower plant populations over time. The sources report visits and fruit production, not population change.
- The sources do not confirm whether colored or dimmed light has the same effect as bright white light. The sources the sources include do not compare light colors for night-blooming flowers.
FAQ
Does light pollution stop night-blooming flowers from being pollinated?
The sources do not say it stops pollination completely. They report a 62 percent drop in visits by nocturnal pollinators in the lit meadows, and a 13 percent drop in fruit production for one local plant. Daytime pollinators still visited the plant in the study.
Which insects are most affected?
The meadow study names moths and certain beetles (Coleoptera) as the nocturnal pollinators that decreased. The sources do not list every insect group.
Why do night-blooming flowers depend on scent?
The review explains that nocturnal pollinators may trade off vision against olfaction when they rely on nectar-rewarding and scented flowers. In dim light, scent helps them find the flower.
Do night-blooming plants need complete darkness?
The sources do not say that. They describe pollinators that work under dim light, and they say artificial light undermines processes governed by dim light.
What is the simplest change for a garden?
Use less light near the plants, shield the fixtures so light points down, and use motion sensors where you can. These steps follow from the points the two sources make.
Are street lights a problem for flowers too?
The meadow study compared artificially lit meadows with unlit ones and reports the drop in visits. It does not specify the type of lamp, so the sources do not separate street lights from garden lights.
Bottom line
Bright light near night-blooming flowers can reduce the nocturnal pollinators those flowers depend on, and the French meadow study linked that loss to lower fruit production. The practical rule from these sources is to keep light off the flowers you want night visitors to find, and to use shielded, motion-activated fixtures elsewhere.
Sources
- CNRS, “A new threat to pollination: the dark side of artificial light,” press release, August 3, 2017. https://www.cnrs.fr/en/press/new-threat-pollination-dark-side-artificial-light
- “Dark Matters: Challenges of Nocturnal Communication Between Plants and Animals in Delivery of Pollination Services,” review article, PubMed Central. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5872639/